From Brentford Hero to Palace Hope: Can Thomas Frank Spark a New Era at Selhurst Park?

Thomas Frank has become Crystal Palace’s fifteenth permanent Premier League manager, and the question now is whether he can become one of the club’s most successful.

The Pierre Sage era came to a premature end last Thursday as Steve Parish made the decision to cut the Frenchman’s time in England short.

I believe I speak on behalf of all Palace fans in wishing Sage well despite the disappointing end to his time in south London. In many ways, he was dealt a difficult hand during a challenging transitional period following Oliver Glasner’s trophy-laden spell. The board did not provide him with the strongest platform from which to succeed, and that undoubtedly made his task more difficult.

However, defensive issues continually troubled the Frenchman and, ultimately, something had to be done to address the deficiencies at the back. Palace were conceding too many goals from set-pieces and counter-attacks, and there was little sign of improvement as results deteriorated. Four consecutive defeats by an aggregate score of 12-1, including a 5-0 loss to arch-rivals Brighton, ultimately proved to be his undoing.

With Coventry City and Hull City the next two opponents in the Premier League, Sage may feel slightly aggrieved that he was not given those additional matches to turn things around. Palace had progressed to the quarter-finals of the League Cup while also remaining in European competition. He always conducted himself with professionalism in press conferences and interviews, meaning most supporters will undoubtedly wish him well in his future endeavours.

In a strange turn of events, it appears he could be set for an immediate return to Lens, where he guided the club to a remarkable second-place finish last season. Hopefully, he will enjoy success wherever his career takes him next.

Yet the show must go on, and Frank’s appointment has finally been confirmed after several days of speculation. A few contractual issues have been resolved, and the Danish manager is now ready to begin work.

Palace supporters have generally responded positively to the appointment and, with the benefit of hindsight, Frank perhaps should have arrived during the summer. Negotiations took place, but the two parties were unable to reach an agreement at that time. Now, however, the opportunity has arisen once more, and Frank returns to management following a nine-month break after his departure from Tottenham Hotspur.

Palace fans will be hoping for the Brentford version of Frank rather than the one seen at Tottenham. Arguably, his legendary status at Brentford should be a more accurate reflection of his abilities than his difficult spell in north London. At Tottenham, pressure arrived immediately from all directions, including the media. Frank may have struggled with the demands of managing one of the country’s biggest clubs, whereas at Brentford he was given the time and patience required to implement his ideas and philosophy.

Frank’s managerial career began at Danish side Brøndby, who had endured a difficult period despite their long-standing reputation as one of Scandinavia’s strongest clubs. He guided them to fourth and third-place finishes, securing qualification for the Europa League, and earned a reputation as one of Denmark’s most promising young coaches.

That reputation attracted interest from England, albeit in an unconventional role. In December 2016, he joined Championship side Brentford as assistant head coach alongside Richard O’Kelly under Dean Smith. Given the West London club’s strong Danish connections, particularly through director of football Rasmus Ankersen, the partnership appeared a natural fit. Many believed Frank was destined to take the top job from the outset.

When Smith departed for his boyhood club Aston Villa, many outside Brentford feared it could disrupt the club’s progress. Internally, however, the board and owner Matthew Benham had complete faith in Frank. That confidence would soon be justified.

Frank was appointed head coach in October 2018 and, following a mid-table finish in his first season, guided the Bees to the Championship Play-Off Final in their final campaign at Griffin Park. The season was heavily disrupted by the Coronavirus pandemic, and Brentford narrowly missed out on promotion after losing to rivals Fulham at Wembley.

However, the following season would become one of the greatest in the club’s history. Brentford reached the semi-finals of the Carabao Cup and returned to the Play-Off Final. This time they were successful, defeating Swansea City 2-0 at Wembley. With the likes of Ivan Toney, Bryan Mbeumo and David Raya playing key roles, Frank masterminded Brentford’s first promotion to the top flight since 1935.

From there, he established Brentford as a solid and consistent Premier League club. Four consecutive seasons in the top flight saw the club finish 13th, 9th, 16th and 10th respectively, with Brentford often appearing closer to European qualification than relegation despite operating on a comparatively modest budget.

Frank built a disciplined side with a strong defensive structure that could become devastating on the counter-attack. It is a model that Palace will hope to replicate.

What Palace will want to avoid, however, is a repeat of Frank’s Tottenham spell. Despite a promising start, including a spirited performance against Paris Saint-Germain in the Super Cup and a 2-0 victory away to Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City, he was unable to recreate his Brentford heroics in north London.

By the time of his final match in charge, Spurs sat 16th in the Premier League table, having suffered a 2-1 defeat to Newcastle United in February. A variety of factors contributed to his struggles, but ultimately the challenge of satisfying a demanding fanbase seeking a particular style of football proved too much.

A number of self-inflicted distractions did not help matters either. An infamous incident involving an Arsenal-branded coffee cup before a match at Bournemouth generated unwanted attention, while several comments made to the media also attracted criticism. At Palace, however, he is unlikely to face the same level of scrutiny.

Instead, he should be afforded time to implement his ideas. Even if results do not arrive immediately, there remain more than enough matches left in the season for improvements to materialise. The key question for Palace supporters concerns what changes he will make tactically.

Sage arguably made the mistake of attempting to replicate Glasner’s trademark 3-4-2-1 system without possessing the same personnel that made it so effective. Frank’s first priority is likely to be building a more organised and defensively secure side, and that may require adjustments to the current setup.

Throughout much of his career, Frank has favoured a 4-2-3-1 formation and enjoyed considerable success using it. However, he has also demonstrated tactical flexibility. Brentford evolved from the expansive attacking style that featured the famous BMW trio of Saïd Benrahma, Bryan Mbeumo and Ollie Watkins in the Championship to a far more structured and pragmatic approach in the Premier League.

His ability to learn and adapt is one of his greatest strengths, and perhaps something his predecessor was unable to do quickly enough to preserve his position.

A clearer indication of Frank’s plans will arrive this weekend with the trip to Frank Lampard’s Coventry City. Palace then host Hull City in the league, with a Europa League clash against Real Sociedad sandwiched in between.

On paper, all three fixtures present opportunities for Palace to build momentum under their new manager. More importantly, they should provide an early insight into how Frank intends to shape his squad and implement his philosophy.

If Palace can benefit from the same qualities that made him such a success at Brentford, there is every reason to believe another positive chapter in the club’s history could be about to begin.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You May Also Like