Sage Is Making Mistakes, But Sacking Him Would Be Premature

Pierre Sage deserves more than eight league games to prove his credentials, yet ruthless modern-day football is preventing this.

Pierre Sage has overseen eight games as Premier League manager, winning two, drawing one and losing five. The Eagles currently sit 17th in the top flight, having also progressed to the last 16 of the Carabao Cup while recording one win, one draw and one defeat from their opening three Europa League fixtures.

Although those results are probably below expectations given the club’s recent success, Palace have undoubtedly been in worse positions. After all, even the great Oliver Glasner endured significant problems during his first full season in charge. After the first eight games of the 2024/25 campaign, Palace had failed to register a victory and had amassed just three points as the South London side languished in the relegation zone.

Yet we all know how that season ended. Glory at Wembley arrived as Palace claimed their first-ever major trophy on the greatest day in the club’s history.

A combination of Frank de Boer and Roy Hodgson managed Palace during the opening seven games of the 2017/18 season. Those matches famously yielded zero points and zero goals, a dreadful Premier League record that may never be matched. Yet Palace fought back and, under Hodgson, climbed to an incredible 11th-place finish that looked inconceivable when he first arrived.

Going back even further, Palace’s 2013/14 campaign provides another example. The club had accumulated just three points from its first 10 matches and sat rock bottom of the table. However, under Tony Pulis, Palace eventually secured an 11th-place finish and comfortably survived a Premier League season for the first time in the club’s history.

These examples from Palace’s recent past suggest the club has faced far worse situations and even greater adversity in its battle to remain in the division. So why are Palace supporters so concerned about the current team and its ability to compete under Sage?

The answer lies in the manner in which Palace are conceding chances and goals so easily. In reality, the two league victories against Fulham and Nottingham Forest could easily have gone the other way. The return of Glasner, in particular, remains puzzling, given that his side only managed to beat Walter Benitez once despite creating numerous opportunities.

The frustration stems from the constant concession of goals that often appear to be carbon copies of one another. Lyon scored two almost identical goals in eastern France during Palace’s Europa League encounter, both arriving from cut-backs after a winger had been given space to advance and pick out an unmarked runner in the penalty area.

Newcastle exploited similar weaknesses at the weekend. Jacob Murphy was allowed to deliver a cross from the right-hand side in front of the travelling supporters, and Will Osula converted from close range without facing a meaningful challenge. Just 11 minutes later, Palace were again exposed as Murphy found the overlapping Amar Dedic, who cut the ball back for Harvey Barnes to finish clinically.

A similar pattern emerged in September against Ipswich. Straightforward deliveries into the penalty area caused havoc, resulting in two first-half headed goals from Emersonn and Leif Davis.

It appears that Sage’s inability to recognise and address these recurring problems has contributed to a level of inconsistency that is unsustainable. The lack of defensive solidity has been highlighted by the fact he has yet to establish a settled back three he trusts.

Whereas the trio of Marc Guehi, Maxence Lacroix and Chris Richards virtually picked itself over the previous two seasons, this campaign has presented a far more difficult challenge. Guehi and Lacroix have moved on, while the club’s new arrivals have been unable to replicate the levels their predecessors consistently delivered.

Honest Ahanor and Axel Disasi arrived on loan from Chelsea, while the injury-prone Takehiro Tomiyasu has been unable to put together a consistent run of appearances. Unsurprisingly, the performances of existing centre-backs Chris Richards and Jaydee Canvot have suffered as they attempt to fill a leadership void that may simply be too large.

The long-term absence of Chadi Riad, however, has not been discussed enough. His excellent performances towards the back end of last season culminated in heroic displays in Leipzig, while he also impressed for Morocco during the summer World Cup.

Sage should take responsibility for failing to settle on a preferred defensive unit. Yet, when opportunities have arisen, those players have hardly made an overwhelming case for inclusion.

The Frenchman has also made some questionable decisions regarding substitutions. His decision to replace Jean-Philippe Mateta with the less mobile Jorgen Strand Larsen in Besiktas appeared particularly strange. Palace lost the focal point who was helping the team advance up the pitch and relieve pressure. The lead disappeared shortly after Mateta’s withdrawal, while much of Palace’s attacking threat vanished with him.

On other occasions, Sage has left creative players such as Dario Osorio on the bench when inspiration has been desperately needed. However, those criticisms could reasonably be described as minor grievances.

What cannot be dismissed so easily is the club’s failure to adequately replace Guehi and Lacroix, a burden that falls squarely on chairman Steve Parish and sporting director Matthew Hobbs.

Arguably, replacing players of that calibre was always going to be difficult, but several targets had been identified before the summer and ultimately did not arrive. Sporting Lisbon’s Ousmane Diomande joined Nottingham Forest, while no further approaches were made for Club Brugge defender Joel Ordonez.

While the on-field issues require immediate attention, questions must also be asked of Hobbs. Since succeeding Dougie Freedman, his major acquisitions have included Strand Larsen for £50 million and the disappointing Brennan Johnson for £35 million. That represents a significant departure from the shrewd recruitment model established by Freedman, who unearthed talents such as Eberechi Eze, Michael Olise and Adam Wharton from the Championship.

Despite all of this, I still believe Sage deserves more time to demonstrate what he is capable of. Until a manager has overseen at least 10 league matches, harsh judgement feels premature. He should be afforded another month to show he possesses the tactical acumen and leadership qualities required to steer Palace out of this difficult position.

Should he ultimately lose his job, most Palace supporters would undoubtedly wish him well. He comes across as an intelligent, likeable and articulate figure who has always been willing to engage openly with the media.

It may simply be that his expansive style is not suited to the demands of the Premier League. If that proves to be the case, it would be a great shame because there is much to admire from an attacking perspective in Sage’s footballing philosophy.

Potential replacements would include the pragmatic Sean Dyche, while former Ipswich manager Kieran McKenna would undoubtedly attract interest given his growing reputation within the game.

Personally, if Sage were relieved of his duties, I would turn to Thomas Frank. He represents a safe pair of hands capable of making Palace difficult to beat while maintaining an aggressive and entertaining attacking identity. Frank would likely get the best from players such as Mateta and Ismaila Sarr, much as he did with Bryan Mbeumo and Yoane Wissa at Brentford.

The Dane could deliver the short-term stability required to ease relegation fears while also possessing the experience necessary to build a competitive squad over the longer term. His track record in west London suggests he would be well equipped for both challenges.

Whether Sage stays or goes, only time will tell. However, given the ruthless nature of modern football and its tendency to consume managers when results turn sour, it is difficult to see him remaining in SE25 for much longer unless both performances and results improve significantly.

 

You May Also Like